Avoiding Neverland

Peter Pan playing the Pipes

Have you ever read Peter Pan?  Not the Disney story, but the original novel by J. M. Barrie?  While I do consider it a work of literary genius, I would hesitate to hand it to young children.  I mean, let’s be honest.  Never Never Land is kind of creepy.  Indians kidnap children and the pirates try to kill everyone, while the fairies drink and have orgies (yep, you read that right).  Tinkerbell calls Wendy a word that starts with a “B” and rhymes with “witch”.  Peter Pan himself isn’t much better.  He is a fun character, but he isn’t intended to be a hero or a role model.  In fact, he can be kind of a jerk in his childish ways.  At the end of the book, all the children, including the Lost Boys, realize that they need to leave Never Never Land and grow up.  Peter Pan is the only one who remains behind, and the reader is actually left feeling a little bit sorry for him.  Neverland is not a place to stay, because people are supposed to grow up.  But for some reason, (probably thanks in part to Disney), Neverland and Peter Pan have become idealized symbols of eternal youth in our culture.

I’ve noticed a trend in my reading.  People are taking a lot longer to grow up than they used to.  Did you know that the concept of being a teenager didn’t exist until the late 1800’s?  Before that a person was either a child or an adult, but nothing in between.  Brett and Alex Harris have already covered the the rise of the teenager in their writings, so I encourage people to check out their article The Myth of Adolescence on The Rebelution website for more information.  Or better yet, read their book!  (See Resources page).  Seriously though, at least read the article.  Teens are a relatively new phenomenon, in the grand scheme of history.

So when I first heard the term “emerging adulthood” used to describe a “new” phase in life between the teen and adult years (starting at around age 19 and lasting until somewhere between 26-30, depending on the individual), I immediately started making the connections to what the Harris boys had written in The Myth of Adolescence.  Once again our culture is finding permissible ways for young people to put off the responsibility of adult life.  Just like people ages 13-19 are now teenagers instead of men and women, people ages 19-30 are now emerging adults instead of just adults.  Jeffrey Jensen Arnett, the developmental psychologist that coined the term, identifies the features of emerging adulthood this way:

  1. “It is the age of identity explorations, of trying out various possibilities, especially in love and work.”
  2. “It is the age of instability.”
  3. “It is the most self-focused age of life.”
  4. “It is the age of feeling in-between, in transition, neither adolescent nor adult.”
  5. “It is the age of possibilities, when hopes flourish, when people have an unparalleled opportunity to transform their lives.” (Emerging Adulthood, p. 7)

Now, Arnett, along with many others, takes a positive view of all of these features of emerging adulthood.  And I agree that identity explorations and possibilities are wonderful things!  In fact, they are so good that I think they should be coming much sooner in life than the twenties! (see what I did there? 🙂 )  However, the instability and feeling in-between can be really unsettling – and for some people it lasts as long as age 30.  Arnett’s research also shows a fundamental shift in how young people view adulthood.  Rather than a beginning of something exciting, many young people view reaching adulthood as the end of independence, spontaneity, and possibilities.  The idea of “settling down” has become synonymous with “boring,” while “responsibility” implies a connotation of “not fun,” so they put it off as long as possible.  And unfortunately, the world has made really easy for them to do that.

The rise of emerging adulthood is a result of several fundamental sources, all combined together to keep people in their late teens and early twenties from growing up.  One is the increase of higher education.  A college degree is almost expected these days, and in order to really get ahead, people are spending time well into their twenties and early thirties pursuing graduate degrees.  This leads to a delay in getting married and establishing a career.  The availability of birth control means people can date and marry without having kids right away.  In fact, people who choose to marry and start a family in their early twenties are often chastised for wanting to “settle down too young,” when about 60 years ago, that was the norm.  And unfortunately, these shifting economic times are a hard reality for many young people right out of college, making it difficult for them to immediately establish their working careers in the fields they studied.  Many people will take whatever job they can to pay the bills, or end up moving back home with their parents because they can’t afford life on their own yet.  Combine all these elements, and people can easily put off reaching the individual responsibilities of adulthood until age 30.

Less tangible, but no less real, emerging adulthood is the result of a cultural mindset that says people need to explore all possible options before making any sort of a commitment.  College students are encouraged to major in what interests them, and if those interests change, they can change their majors as many times as they want.  Arnett’s research indicates that most incoming college freshmen may have a vague idea of a subject they want to study, but they have not made any kind of definite career choice as the purpose of their collegiate studies.  They are often more interested in the freedom and social opportunities college life provides.  The result of all this unfocused major-changing is that it’s taking longer for people to graduate.  Getting out of college in four years is becoming less common, and nearly half of undergraduate students are over 25 years old (Emerging Adulthood p.125).  Catch phrases like “keeping my options open,” “becoming well-rounded,” “getting in touch with myself,” “bouncing around,” and “building a lot of experience” have become common among people in their twenties.  Those phrases aren’t inherently bad, but when used as an excuse to keep from choosing a path and committing to it, they allow young people to avoid growing up.

My generation is a good example of emerging adults.  I know and work with people well into their late twenties who still live with their parents.  I’ve talked with others who envy my stable marriage, but aren’t willing to take the steps I took to get there.  They’ve bought into the messages of emerging adulthood.  You see, instead of training for a given career, we were fed various life philosophies, encouraged to “explore the options” and take time to “discover ourselves.”  Instead of preparing for marriage and family, society encouraged us to date casually to “find out what we liked.”  The common thread is an overwhelming avoidance of commitment – to anything!  The result is a generation that struggles with self-identity, career instability, and a whole slew of relationship baggage.

But what I don’t understand is why.  So many people my age have sacrificed the pride of achievement, success, and reaching goals for the idea of “keeping options open.”  They have sacrificed fulfilling relationships for a string of Friday night dates.  They have sacrificed purpose and ambition for a vague concept of “being free to do their own thing.”  Maybe they fear being tied down, or they don’t want responsibility, or maybe they just don’t what it is that they’re supposed to be doing.  Whatever the cause, too many people my age are drifting into adulthood instead of launching into it.

Possibilities are great, but at some point a person needs to choose something to actively pursue in order that something great can become reality.  That’s when life becomes exhilarating – when possibilities stop floating intangibly just beyond reach and some of them become the reality of life.  That’s when dreams are achieved instead just imagined.  I love the idea of identity explorations and researching a wide range career possibilities to find the best individual fit – I just want to see those things started at the teen level instead.  Arnett doesn’t seem to think teens are capable of accurate identity exploration, but I think they are, if they were just given the right guidance.

Being absolutely honest?  This trend scares me.  In just the span of about 120 years, society has found culturally acceptable ways for people to put off adulthood an extra 15-20 years after they leave childhood.  That’s not ok!  And who’s to say that it’ll stop now?  When will “40 become the new 20?”  When will we reach a time when people just don’t grow up at all?  I pray that teens everywhere are taking the Harris boys’ message to heart and establishing themselves as the young adults they are meant to be, because I don’t want to live in Neverland.  That place is scary.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Avoiding Neverland

  1. I guess I’m a semi-emerging adult. I took the extra time to go to grad school (and I still live with my parents) but all of it was done with a goal in mind. I didn’t do it to avoid commitment. In reality I couldn’t find a job that would allow me to live on my own while a full-time grad student. So I chose to stick with my parents a bit longer and hustle through grad school so that I can now find a good job without the added stress of school. I also chose to stay at home because I committed to help my mother through some family issues. Overall, though, I agree with your trepidation about the growing trend of prolonged adolescence.

    Like

    • I know. I am by no means saying that everyone who stays at home after college is doing so out of a lack of commitment. I know that there are often very valid reasons for it. You also have career goals that you are very actively pursuing, as well as responsibilities to your family that others may not have. I, too, fall into categories of emerging adulthood. Seven jobs in three states in four years is by no means “settled”! It’s more that I want to see people commit to adulthood, instead of drifting into it.

      Like

  2. Interesting piece, Christine, but I agree that the comment above reveals there are more complex issues & variables involved in these changes you outline. As far as marriage is concerned, you were truly blessed in the stable marriage that God brought to your life when He did. While you may see that you were willing take the steps to get there [which you indicate some may not have been so willing], be careful not to insert your own experience and generalize into the situation of others in which the variables are quite different than your own. Additionally, college education, at least for many in our area here in Michigan, is no longer a simple 4 year experience, due to economic trends right now. Technical training is becoming more ‘acceptable’ as a starting point in high school.

    So many psychosocial & cultural variables to be considered, as well as the changes in shifting political climates & economic conditions of our time! And a key component is the shifting spiritual foundations!! While I urge you to be careful in your applications, I truly do applaud you for studying this complex issue with a passion to guide young people in your career. May God guide you in your pursuit!

    While you see the current trend as being scary, follow the trends down through the centuries,… It becomes less scary, especially as you study “emerging communities” centuries past… Just a very fascinating cycle.

    Just my thoughts to add to this discussion. Enjoying reading your blog!

    Like

  3. Pingback: The Changing Culture of Adulthood: Why 30 is the new 25. :) « The Narcissistic Anthropologist

  4. There are a couple of books that you might find interesting. “Slouching Toward Adulthood: Observations from the Not-So-Empty Nest” by Sally Koslow and also “Escaping the Endless Adolescence: How We Can Help Our Teenagers Grow Up Before They Grow Old” by Joseph Allen and Claudia Worrell Allen where Chapter 1 is entitled “Is Twenty-five the New Fifteen?” This is definetly a phenomenon that is present. I have experienced it personally.

    Like

  5. I just wanted to say I am so happy I stumbled across your blog and read this post. I’ve been having a similar train of thought myself yet hadn’t had enough time to fully contemplate the issue. I work in a large chain bookstore and day in and day out I seen teens and young people coming in, getting caramel frappuccinos in our cafe and browsing the YA aisles or sitting on the floor texting their friends. I find I have a hard time understanding their culture. As someone in my (very early) twenties, I have an unusual drive and ambition to do all the things you get to do as an adult: build my own business, buy a house, get married, get advanced degrees while keeping a job and a roof over my head. I’ve had varying amounts of success in my pursuit towards these goals but at least I have them as goals. I’m not seeing that with these teens, and as you said, this “commitment-phobic” attitude is all too pervasive. I really wish I knew where they were getting the idea that the moment you decide to do something and put the work into it, you’re stuck with that choice for life. I changed my career three times before I turned twenty but at least I pursued each one with the passion I knew it deserved. If we could curb this idea of “making decisions equals settling down”, I think our teens would be ten times more productive, happier, and would likely help them find their true identity because nothing convinces you faster of not being something than by being it fully and discovering that’s not who you are.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s